Charcoal is burnt wood. Why does it burn hotter?
Can't play sound? The illustrated version is right below.
Read the transcript
The full narration of the video.
It takes five kilos of wood to make one kilo of charcoal, yet charcoal burns far hotter. Skewer stalls and copper hotpots all cook over charcoal. Start with the result: fan charcoal and it passes 1,100 degrees Celsius, hot enough for ancient smiths to smelt iron.
A wood fire? Tall flames, choking smoke, and heat that comes and goes. Same tree, so why is it hotter as charcoal? Let's rewind and see how charcoal is made. To make charcoal, you seal wood in a kiln with barely any air and let it smoulder for days.
Water leaves first. Even dried firewood is about one fifth water by weight. Next come flammable gases. Most of the wood drifts off this way. What's left is a black skeleton made almost entirely of carbon. That's charcoal.
It's a bit like reducing a sauce: the water boils away, a pot shrinks to a bowl, and every spoonful is richer. Charcoal is the same: kilo for kilo, it holds nearly twice the heat of dry wood. But reducing only removes water. The kiln also drives off those flammable gases, which could have made heat too.
Add it up: turning five kilos of wood into one kilo of charcoal spends more than half the heat inside the kiln. This step has a name: carbonization. Reducing stands for carbonization, what boils off is the water and gas, and the rich sauce left is this lump of charcoal.
Snap a lump open and you can still see the growth rings and grain. So why is charcoal hotter? Back to the skewer stall, and watch two fires burn. Lit firewood first spends heat drying out its own water, and that heat flies off as steam.
Then the heated wood gives off gas, and the gas catches fire in the air. That's the flame you see. The flames float above and mix with lots of cool air, so the heat spreads out, and whatever doesn't burn becomes black smoke. Charcoal skips all that. The water and gas were driven off back in the kiln.
Air touches the charcoal's surface directly, carbon and oxygen join right there, and the heat is released on the lump itself. So charcoal barely flames. It glows red all through, with the heat packed into one small spot. That's exactly what skewers need: steady heat, little smoke, rising straight up from below.
In fact, a wood fire gets there on its own in the end. Late at night, when a campfire's flames die and only a red glow remains, it's burning the charcoal it made of itself. Where have you seen a fire end as nothing but a smokeless red glow?
Five pounds of wood
for one pound of charcoal
Pound for pound, charcoal holds almost twice the heat of dry wood.
But it takes five pounds of wood to make one pound of charcoal, so more than half the heat is spent in the kiln.
Less heat in total, yet a hotter fire: fanned with air, charcoal passes 1100°C, which is how ancient smiths smelted iron. The difference is not how much heat there is, but where it comes out.
Days in a
smothered kiln
Making charcoal is not setting wood on fire. The wood is shut in a kiln with only a little air and heated for days. It gets very hot inside, but there is too little oxygen for open flame. One by one, things are driven out of the wood:
This step is called carbonization. Snap a piece of charcoal and you can still see the growth rings and grain: the skeleton the wood left behind.
Like reducing a sauce,
almost
Reducing matches carbonization. The water that boils off matches the water and gases. The rich sauce left over is the charcoal in your hand.
Two fires,
heat in different places
Late at night a campfire loses its flames and leaves a pile of red glow. What is burning then is the charcoal the wood turned into.
Keep charcoal outdoors
does not mean safe Charcoal short of oxygen gives off carbon monoxide, which has no color and no smell. Never burn charcoal for heat in a room, car, or tent, and grill only where air moves freely.
stays on the lump
Quick check
Why does charcoal burn hotter than the wood it came from?
Like reducing a sauce: water boils off and every spoon gets richer. Charcoal has nothing to burn off first, so heat stays on the lump.


