← ELI5 中文
EXPLAINED SIMPLY

What is a
magic state?

For anyone who sees quantum computer headlines but can’t tell what’s holding them back
No. 348Inside Computers & the InternetPart 36 of 36Inspired by RedditFact-checked Oct 22, 2026
Video2:36 · English voice (AI) · English subtitles

Can't play sound? The illustrated version is right below.

Read the transcript

The full narration of the video.

Up to ninety-five percent of a quantum computer's effort may go into making magic. That's an estimate Google has cited. Scientists really do call the thing a magic state. Why would a computer spend so much effort making magic?

Start with what a quantum computer fears most. Its tiny parts, called qubits, are incredibly fragile. A little heat, a little shaking, and they slip. So scientists add error correction: several qubits guard the same piece of information, and whichever one drifts gets pushed right back. The catch: error correction can only watch over a few kinds of moves.

Picture a machine whose knobs only turn in whole notches. Every twist is exactly a quarter turn, and it clicks into place. Anything sitting in a notch shows the slightest slip at once, so error correction can keep it in line. But whole notches have a big flaw: an ordinary computer can follow along and get the same answer. The quantum computer is no better.

To truly beat an ordinary computer, it has to turn half a notch: an eighth of a turn. Half a notch doesn't click into anything. If it slips a little while turning, error correction can't tell a deliberate turn from a mistake. The trick: don't turn it on the machine at all.

First turn a separate part to half a notch off to the side, test it, then plug it in. Plugging it in does that half-notch turn for the machine. That pre-turned part is the magic state. It's really just a qubit turned to that eighth-of-a-turn angle. It's called magic because with it, a whole-notch machine can compute anything.

Here's the hard part: each one is used up once it's plugged in. A truly useful problem burns through more magic states than you can count. And turning them off to the side goes wrong too. The classic fix is called distillation: take fifteen slightly-off parts and run them through one test together. Pass, and you get one far more accurate part; fail, and the whole batch is thrown away.

Refine layer after layer like that, and the magic-state workshop takes over most of the machine. This October, Google published a new method in the journal Science, called cultivation. Instead of refining fifteen into one, a single part is checked as it's turned, and tossed and restarted the moment something's off.

The parts that survive have about forty times fewer errors, roughly one mistake in ten thousand. Still, this was a test on a small chip, and a truly useful quantum computer is a long way off. In future quantum computers, will the magic workshop keep shrinking, or always take up most of the machine? Nobody knows yet. Which side are you on?

1

A part turned in advance

A magic state is a part turned to “half a notch” off to the side, tested, and then plugged into the quantum computer.

Google has cited an estimate that future quantum computers might spend up to 95% of their capacity making them.

2

A machine that only turns in whole notches

A quantum computer’s tiny parts are called qubits. A little heat or shaking makes them slip. So they get error correction: several qubits guard the same information, and whichever one drifts gets pushed back.

The catch: error correction can only watch over a few kinds of moves. Picture a knob where every twist is exactly a quarter turn and clicks into a notch. In a notch, the slightest slip shows at once.

WHOLE NOTCHES ONLY
Errors stay in check
But an ordinary computer can follow along and get the same answer. The quantum computer is no better.
HALF A NOTCH
Needed to beat ordinary computers
Half a notch is an eighth of a turn. It doesn’t click into anything, so if it slips, error correction can’t tell a deliberate turn from a mistake.

The hard half-notch move is called the “T gate”. The whole-notch moves are called “Clifford operations”.

3

Don’t turn it on the machine

Turn it asideTake a separate qubit and turn it an eighth of a turn.
Test itThrow out the off ones, keep the good ones.
Plug it inPlugging it in does the half-notch turn for the machine.

That part is the magic state. It’s really just a qubit turned to that eighth-of-a-turn angle. It’s called magic because with it, a whole-notch machine can compute anything.

The real “plugging in” is called gate teleportation: a few whole-notch moves plus one measurement carry the half notch from the part onto the qubit being computed.

4

Why up to 95% of the effort?

Each magic state is used up once it’s plugged in; you can’t take it back out. A truly useful problem burns through more of them than you can count.

And turning them off to the side goes wrong too. The classic fix is distillation: run fifteen slightly-off parts through one test together. Pass, and you get one far more accurate part; fail, and the whole batch is thrown away. Layer after layer, the magic-state workshop takes over most of the machine.

Fifteen in, one out One layer not accurate enough? Add another. So the workshop keeps growing.
5

Google’s new way to make them

In October 2026, Google published “cultivation” in the journal Science: instead of refining fifteen into one, a single part is checked as it’s turned, and tossed and restarted the moment something’s off.

On Google’s Willow chip, the parts that survived had about 40 times fewer errors: roughly one mistake in ten thousand.

This was still a test on a small chip. A truly useful quantum computer is a long way off.

The hardest part
isn’t computing.
It’s turning half a notch right.
Will the magic workshop keep shrinking, or always take up most of the machine? Nobody knows yet.
UP NEXT

How a Web Page Gets Made

Using a sign-up page for a seafood dinner: walls, paint, switches, a shared notebook and a street address, no code required.

No. 1 · 5 minKeep going →
← Back to ELI5