← ELI5 中文
ELI5

Why we can
always find
an excuse

Written for people who never studied psychology
About excuses, something everyone does and everyone denies
No. 14Thinking ClearlyPart 2 of 12
1

In one sentence

An excuse isn't really for other people. It is a board you put between yourself and "I can't".

So the people best at making excuses are often not the ones who care least.
They are the ones most afraid they "really can't".

2

How is it different
from lying?

LYING
Knows the truth, says something false
You know the facts and say something else. Get caught and it's over, so liars feel uneasy.
EXCUSE
Every word is true
You really were in a meeting, really had a fever, really missed the bus. All checkable, so you speak with a clear conscience, and nobody can argue back.

That is what makes excuses so powerful: they need no false words.
They just take a true fact and park it right behind the question "when will you do it?"

3

How does it
protect you?

1. Dig a hole firstStay up late, skip preparing, wait until the last day. Not always on purpose.
2. It doesn't get doneMaybe it really failed, or maybe you simply never did it
3. The hole takes the blame"If I had prepared it would have been different." Notice nobody can ever prove that wrong.
4. "I actually can" stays intactWhat is never tested can never be disproved

A famous 1978 experiment: people finished a test and were told "you did great". Then they chose a pill. One was said to boost performance, the other to hurt it.
Many picked the one that hurts.
If the next round goes badly, there is something to blame.

4

Why the tighter things are,
the more likely it is

This isn't a willpower problem. Your mind is occupied.

A 2013 study gave the same set of tests to sugarcane farmers in India: once before harvest, once after. The same person scored clearly worse before harvest, when money was tight.

HOW BIG IS THE GAP
About the same as a full night without sleep

The researchers worked it out as roughly 13 points lost on an IQ test. The farmers didn't get dumber. "Not enough money" was running in the background all the time and filling their minds.

When your mind is full, you can only see the one square in front of you.
Explaining away a failure in advance is the cheapest way to live.
The energy saved has to last through tomorrow.

5

Why other people's are obvious
and ours are "reasons"

Because what you can see is different.

When it's you, you see the whole day: when you got up, how bad traffic was, what last-minute work landed, how your body felt. When it's someone else, you only see one result: they didn't hand it in.

The interesting part: psychologists used to think this bias was everywhere. A 2006 analysis pooling 173 studies found it isn't that widespread, but it does hold for failures and mistakes.
In other words, the bias is real exactly where it matters most.

6

The one fix that has
been tested again and again

Not making a resolution, not vowing, not "I will definitely do it".

It is turning "I will do it" into a sentence with a place and a time:

THE FORMULA
"Thursday at 8 p.m.,
at my desk, I will do this."

A 2006 analysis pooling 94 studies and over eight thousand people found that just rewriting an intention as a "when, where, what" sentence clearly raised the rate of follow-through, an effect that counts as medium to large in psychology.

Why does something so simple work?
Because an excuse can only block the question "should I do it?"
It can't block a time slot that is already written down. When the time comes there are only two options, do it or don't, and no third explanation.

7

One thing
this page won't do

It is not for scolding people "You're just making excuses" is itself a board too,
one that blocks the thought "am I like that too?"

Making excuses isn't bad character. It is a protection a person grows when there is no room left. Press anyone into that spot and they will grow the same thing.
So what should I do with this?
Don't rush to tear down someone else's board. That only makes them grip it tighter.

When you look at others, assume there is a whole day behind them that you can't see. You'll scold a lot fewer people.

When you look at yourself, ask just one thing:
"Which day, what time, where?"
If you can answer, that's a plan.
If you can't, what you just said was an excuse.
No shame needed. Spotting it is enough, and spotting it is what lets you change.

Where these claims come from

UP NEXT

Done, But Nobody Can See It

The costliest mistakes don't throw errors: everything ran smoothly, yet the thing never arrived. A real incident, plus two rules you can use today.

No. 15 · 4 minKeep going →
← Back to ELI5